| Cartoons & Comics / Traditional Media / Comics / Pages | ©2008-2013 ~maaria |
The Journal Portal
Browse Journals |
Polls |
deviantART [dee·vee·un'nt·ART]
Keep in Touch!
|
Deviousness |
OH, my GAWD!!! This is amazing!! Most artists, and I mean no offense to them, aren't very coherent story tellers, and their work, however beautiful their art may be, falls either flat and monotonous or incomprehensible. You are certainly remarkably accomplished, with all things considered!
First off, there's no doubt that your artwork is amazing; it's very crisp and clean, making it a pleasure to look at. Secondly, the backgrounds aren't too distracting, and they set up the mood quite nicely. Because it's never too detailed for it's own good, I'm never distracted from the actual characters themselves; you still, however, provide enough detail in the background to give the reader a sense of where they are. The mood being portrayed in each panel is also vital to portray not just by the characters' expressions and body language, but by the background. Since the focus isn't on the background itself (unless setting up a panel dedicated to give the reader a sense of where they are, in which case it'd be preferably in high detail), being able to emphasize the mood while not being too distracting is key.
What I'm really focusing on, though, is the writing portion of the comic, and how it and the artwork form a unity to create the manga itself.
To start simple, you divide the panels with pictures and words very smoothly. Moreover, if I view the comic in small view, I can still easily see how the comic flows!! I'm impressed with how you incorporate the pictures with your word bubbles to create that invisible pathway from start to finish. In addition to, that pathway is also supposed to help the reader determine whether the comic reads from left to right or vice versa. From the first and second panel, you made that very clear. The story is very solid on it's own, as well. Reading your comments, I'd say you've reached your goal when you say you're aiming for a narrative that doesn't explain itself too much. Even though barely any information is given on the plot itself, the reader can narrow things down by what you already have. I can see by other user comments that they can assume quite a bit. A job well done!
Ahem!! Anyway, just because I'm rewarding you a job well done doesn't mean I'm not going to point out some flaws, although not many.
First off, [second page third panel] actually does have a flow issue. I don't think you should have drawn her legs out of the panel because it directed me to the wrong word bubble, making me want to read what she was saying instead of starting off where you would like me to.
Second mistake I see would also be the third panel on the following page. All those tiny little pebbles in the background are distracting!
This makes me feel that you've really practiced hard on this project, and dedicated to making it happen. If it's not too much to ask, I'd greatly suggest a kind of... not a tutorial, exactly, but something to show off the techniques you used and something to give some hints and advice to comic artists out there! Also, if you have any websites or books you learned from, I'd love to hear about them If you learned from a class you took, could you share some stuff you learned?
I greatly enjoyed reading this first page! I'll definitely be reading the rest, and I'll be letting you know if I see anything that doesn't seem right.
Heh, I personally have very little patience for comics that are difficult to read. If the page flow and images aren't easily comprehensible, there's no point in drawing a comic to begin with! "Consider the reader", that's my top priority, so I'm really careful to make the page layouts as coherent as possible. Then I just figure out the emphasis I want to put in each panel and draw everything according to that.
This isn't my first time drawing comics, I actually have some history with this stuff... I used to draw a webcomic back in highschool and after that I've done a few shorter projects too. Phantomland will probably become a pretty long and ambitious personal project of mine so I'm working hard to make it decent quality right from the start :>
I actually studied comics for a year at this institute but I don't think I got a lot out of it, other than getting my hands on some interesting rarities. My advice would be to just read a lot of good comics and pay attention to the techniques used in them, I guess. Fullmetal Alchemist and Dogs are great examples if you're going for manga-style storytelling in particular.
I'm glad you liked the comic though! I hope you'll someday get to read the print version too :D
That's a very good technique, drawing things according to the emphasis of each panel. It makes it easier to layout the flow of the rest of the page. If a comic isn't easy to follow, then I can't concentrate on what's going on.
I need to focus on drawing comics while I'm wokring on improving everything else. Currently I'm working on action poses, and expressions, and especially backgrounds. My people tend to look stiff, and their faces don't tell much about their character
It's wonderful to hear you're putting a lot of effort into this! I'm definitely going to have to ask for your book for Christmas! It started out great, and I want to see how it ends.
I love FML! I don't really have a lot of time to read it all at once or anything, but of what I've read, it's great! A month ago I just started Dogs,and wow! I love the artist's style. The prelude was kind of hard to follow at first, but after the first chapter, things started making plenty of sense. It's just the first story that I didn't quite get.
Anyway, once I convince my parents to allow me to use their paypal account to buy Phantomland, I'll be eagerly awaiting it's arrival at my doorstep